? Explanation of report features   View original ACBLscore output
Download hands in PBN or PDF format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Field strength:  Mean: 488 MP  Geomean: 239 MP
(based on 20 players)
★ ★ ★  Masterpoint Winners  ★ ★ ★
Partnership Pct Rank MP
Anisuz Zaman - Hideki Kitamura 57.50 1st A 1.88
James Ciolli - Manu Chaganlal 56.88 2nd A 1.32
Rose Vogt - Thomas Turner 56.25 3rd A 0.94
Carol Adair - Cheryl Rankin 54.38 4th A 0.66
EVENT>Wednesday Evening Pairs  |SESSION>Wednesday Eve|SECTION> E
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>July 12, 2017      |SANCTION>ST1707051 | 07/12/2017 21:16|EVENT CODE>090P
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> John Lagodimos  |RATING>STAC, CLUB>260323            |MOVEMENT>ONE WINNER
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   40.0 |TOP>   4 |MP LIMITS>None/2000/750  |CLUB>Eastlake Bridge Club
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=10/B=9/C=9                      ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Rosemary Buswell       Elisabeth Cogdill        C    .     .     .     37.50  46.88          
 2 Kenneth Gestiehr       Beverly Stebbins         C    .     .     .     36.50  45.63          
 3 Judi Bunch             Hiroko Kitamura          C    .     .     .     40.50  50.63          
 4 Bill Osgood            Dave Cleary              C    .     .     .     30.50  38.13          
 5 Thomas Turner          Rose Vogt                C    3     3     3     45.00  56.25  0.94(A) 
 6 John Dusharme          Merle Schneidewind       C    .     .     .     39.00  48.75          
 7 Anisuz Zaman           Hideki Kitamura          C    1     1     1     46.00  57.50  1.88(A) 
 8 Cheryl Rankin          Carol Adair              C    4     4     4     43.50  54.38  0.66(A) 
 9 Manu Chaganlal         James Ciolli             C    2     2     2     45.50  56.88  1.32(A) 
10 Kathie Angione         John Peter Lagodimos     A    NE    .     .     36.00  45.00          
                                          Totals                         400.00       

Hands and Results
1 ♠A53
A73
Q73
♣QJT3
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠QT92
QJ62
T84
♣AK
♠KJ876
K
AK9652
♣4
♠4
T9854
J
♣987652
13
1214
1
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣  ♦1 ♥6 ♠1 NT2
EW: 4 5♠ 5NT  ♣5 ♥6
LoTT: 19 - 19 = 0
Par: -460 5NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          4.00   0.00  5♠ E -1   T  5-Turner-Vogt vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        200    3.00   1.00  2♠ E +3       3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        450    1.50   2.50  5♠ E      ♣4  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
        450    1.50   2.50  4♠ E +1   J  8-Rankin-Adair vs 2-Gestiehr-Stebbins
        480    0.00   4.00  5♠ E +1   J  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
2 ♠Q92
T92
KJ952
♣73
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠AK86
J43
764
♣KT8
♠T75
AK
QT
♣AJ9542
♠J43
Q8765
A83
♣Q6
6
1114
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣3 ♦6 ♥6 ♠3 NT3
EW: 4♣ 1 4♠ 2NT  ♦6
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: -420 4♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          4.00   0.00  3N W -1   5  8-Rankin-Adair vs 2-Gestiehr-Stebbins
        130    3.00   1.00  2♣ E +2   8  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
        420    2.00   2.00  4♠ E      A  5-Turner-Vogt vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        430    0.50   3.50  3N E +1   8  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        430    0.50   3.50  3N E +1   6  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
3 ♠T84
J3
A9872
♣A94
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠AJ7
AT85
KJ5
♣KQ7
♠K932
Q42
643
♣JT8
♠Q65
K976
QT
♣6532
9
186
7
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣4/5 ♦5 ♥4 ♠3 NT4
EW: 2/3♣ 2 3 3/4♠ 3NT
LoTT: 15 - 14 = +1
Par: -620 4♠-W
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  300          3.50   0.50  2N W -3   8  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
  300          3.50   0.50  3♠ E -3   Q  8-Rankin-Adair vs 2-Gestiehr-Stebbins
  200          2.00   2.00  3N W -2   7  5-Turner-Vogt vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  100          1.00   3.00  2 W -1   A  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        180    0.00   4.00  1N W +3   7  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
4 ♠A87
54
J832
♣AKJ8
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠QJ9
AQT8
95
♣T532
♠65
97632
QT64
♣97
♠KT432
KJ
AK7
♣Q64
13
92
16
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4/5♣ 2 4/5♠ 2/3NT  ♥6
EW: 1  ♣2 ♦4 ♠2 NT2
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +650 5♠-S
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  600          3.00   1.00  3N S      8  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
  600          3.00   1.00  3N S      8  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
  600          3.00   1.00  3N S      8  5-Turner-Vogt vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        100    0.50   3.50  3N N -1   3  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        100    0.50   3.50  6♠ N -1   9  8-Rankin-Adair vs 2-Gestiehr-Stebbins
5 ♠9843
942
J643
♣K6
Dlr: North
Vul: N-S
♠AKJ6
Q75
2
♣AQT98
♠Q752
T3
K975
♣J42
♠T
AKJ86
AQT8
♣753
4
166
14
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2 3  ♣4 ♠5 NT6
EW: 2♣ 2/1♠  ♦5 ♥4 NT6
LoTT: 17 - 16 = +1
Par: +100 3♠*-E-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.00   1.00  4♠ E -1   A  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
   50          3.00   1.00  3♠ E -1   ♠T  9-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 3-Bunch-Kitamura
   50          3.00   1.00  2♠ W -1   9  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
        110    1.00   3.00  3♣ W      9  5-Turner-Vogt vs 8-Rankin-Adair
        140    0.00   4.00  3♠ E      A  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
6 ♠A62
97
Q75
♣98763
Dlr: East
Vul: E-W
♠J54
2
KJ9864
♣AKQ
♠QT973
QT83
32
♣JT
♠K8
AKJ654
AT
♣542
6
145
15
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2/3♣ 2 2NT  ♦6 ♠5/6
EW: 1 1♠  ♣3 ♥5/4 NT5
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +120 2NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          4.00   0.00  3 W -1   9  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
         50    2.50   1.50  3N N -1   2  9-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 3-Bunch-Kitamura
         50    2.50   1.50  3 S -1   ♠5  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        100    0.50   3.50  4 S -2   ♣A  5-Turner-Vogt vs 8-Rankin-Adair
        100    0.50   3.50  3 S -2   ♣A  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
7 ♠96
JT643
AJ4
♣AQJ
Dlr: South
Vul: Both
♠JT83
72
Q93
♣KT83
♠KQ
AQ95
K7652
♣52
♠A7542
K8
T8
♣9764
13
614
7
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♣ 2 2♠ 2NT  ♦6
EW: 1  ♣6/5 ♥5 ♠5 NT5
LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: +120 2NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  200          4.00   0.00  3* E -1  K  5-Turner-Vogt vs 8-Rankin-Adair
  140          3.00   1.00  2 N +1   ♣5  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
  120          2.00   2.00  1N N +1   6  9-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 3-Bunch-Kitamura
         90    0.50   3.50  2 E      K  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
         90    0.50   3.50  2 E      K  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
8 ♠92
K4
96432
♣9752
Dlr: West
Vul: None
♠J64
Q652
JT
♣AKQT
♠T8
AT83
AQ875
♣J8
♠AKQ753
J97
K
♣643
3
1311
13
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣3 ♦3 ♥2 ♠6 NT4
EW: 2♣ 3 3 1♠ 1NT
LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -140 3-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.50   0.50  3N E -2   ♠A  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
  100          3.50   0.50  4 E -2   ♠A  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
   50          2.00   2.00  4 E -1   ♠A  9-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 3-Bunch-Kitamura
        110    1.00   3.00  2 W      ♠9  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        500    0.00   4.00  4♠* S -3  ♣A  5-Turner-Vogt vs 8-Rankin-Adair
9 ♠KT985
987
K2
♣K73
Dlr: North
Vul: E-W
♠4
KQ2
T64
♣QJ9652
♠-
J654
AQJ9853
♣A4
♠AQJ7632
AT3
7
♣T8
9
812
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♠ 2/-NT
       ♣2 ♦1 ♥1 NT8/4
EW: 5♣ 6 5  ♠5 NT5
LoTT: 20 - 22 = -2
Par: -800 6NT*-N/6♠*-NS-4
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  200          4.00   0.00  1N E -2   4  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 8-Rankin-Adair
         50    3.00   1.00  3♠ S -1   T  10-Angione-Lagodimos vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
        100    2.00   2.00  4♠ S -2   T  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
        150    1.00   3.00  5♠ S -3   T  5-Turner-Vogt vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        500    0.00   4.00  5♠* S -3  4  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
10 ♠K9752
KJ8
AT87
♣K
Dlr: East
Vul: Both
♠JT83
AQ
KQJ53
♣Q2
♠Q64
74
42
♣AJT963
♠A
T96532
96
♣8754
14
157
4
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3  ♣3 ♦5 ♠6 NT4
EW: 3♣ 1 1NT  ♥3 ♠6
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +140 3-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  170          4.00   0.00  2 S +2   ♣Q  10-Angione-Lagodimos vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
         90    3.00   1.00  1N E      T  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 8-Rankin-Adair
        110    2.00   2.00  3♣ E      ♠K  5-Turner-Vogt vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        150    1.00   3.00  2N W +1   ♠5  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
        200    0.00   4.00  1♠ N -2   4  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
11 ♠Q86
85
KQ85
♣AQ53
Dlr: South
Vul: None
♠K75
AJ762
6
♣7642
♠A943
K4
JT32
♣T98
♠JT2
QT93
A974
♣KJ
13
88
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2 2NT  ♣6 ♥6 ♠6
EW: 1  ♣5 ♦5 ♠6 NT5
LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: +120 2NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  400          4.00   0.00  3N N      ♠3  5-Turner-Vogt vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
  120          3.00   1.00  2N N      ♠3  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 8-Rankin-Adair
         50    1.50   2.50  3N N -1   ♠3  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
         50    1.50   2.50  2 S -1   6  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        150    0.00   4.00  3♣ N -3       10-Angione-Lagodimos vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
12 ♠Q72
Q972
QJ2
♣Q93
Dlr: West
Vul: N-S
♠KJ86
AJ85
AT64
♣K
♠A5
KT
873
♣AJT742
♠T943
643
K95
♣865
9
1612
3
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣1 ♦2 ♥3 ♠2 NT2
EW: 6♣ 5 4 4♠ 4NT
LoTT: 15 - 14 = +1
Par: -920 6♣-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        430    4.00   0.00  3N W +1   2  10-Angione-Lagodimos vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
        460    2.00   2.00  3N W +2   2  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
        460    2.00   2.00  3N E +2   ♠3  5-Turner-Vogt vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        460    2.00   2.00  3N E +2   5  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        490    0.00   4.00  3N E +3   ♠T  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 8-Rankin-Adair
13 ♠95
754
AQ8732
♣87
Dlr: North
Vul: Both
♠AQ84
932
J4
♣A964
♠J732
KT
KT96
♣QJT
♠KT6
AQJ86
5
♣K532
6
1110
13
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1  ♣5 ♦6 ♠4 NT6
EW: 2♣ 1 3♠ 1/-NT
       ♥5 NT7/6
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -140 3♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        100    4.00   0.00  2 S -1   J  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        170    2.00   2.00  3♠ E +1   5  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 8-Rankin-Adair
        170    2.00   2.00  3♠ E +1       6-Dusharme-Schneidewind vs 5-Turner-Vogt
        170    2.00   2.00  2♠ E +2   5  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        200    0.00   4.00  3 S -2   J  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
14 ♠Q63
A9643
K
♣T985
Dlr: East
Vul: None
♠72
J87
JT7532
♣J7
♠J98
QT2
AQ8
♣A632
♠AKT54
K5
964
♣KQ4
9
313
15
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 4 5♠  ♦5 NT6
EW: 1  ♣4/3 ♥3 ♠2 NT6
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +450 5♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  450          4.00   0.00  4♠ S +1   ♣J  6-Dusharme-Schneidewind vs 5-Turner-Vogt
  170          2.00   2.00  2♠ S +2   ♣J  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
  170          2.00   2.00  2♠ S +2   ♣J  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
  170          2.00   2.00  2♠ S +2   ♣J  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        150    0.00   4.00  3N S -3   5  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 8-Rankin-Adair
15 ♠T4
A543
K742
♣543
Dlr: South
Vul: N-S
♠7652
982
Q
♣KQJ87
♠KQ3
K6
JT85
♣AT62
♠AJ98
QJT7
A963
♣9
7
813
12
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2 2  ♣4 ♠6 NT6
EW: 3♣ 1♠ 1NT  ♦5 ♥4
LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: -110 3♣-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  140          4.00   0.00  3 N      ♠K  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
  100          2.50   1.50  3N E -2   7  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 8-Rankin-Adair
  100          2.50   1.50  3♠ W -2   2  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        100    1.00   3.00  3 N -1   J  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        200    0.00   4.00  3 N -2   ♣A  6-Dusharme-Schneidewind vs 5-Turner-Vogt
16 ♠92
K853
AQ964
♣J3
Dlr: West
Vul: E-W
♠43
AQ97
J
♣A97542
♠AKJT75
T64
T732
♣-
♠Q86
J2
K85
♣KQT86
10
118
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1  ♣6 ♥5 ♠4 NT6
EW: 1♣ 1/2 3/2♠  ♦5 NT6
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -140 3♠-E
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          4.00   0.00  4♠ E -1   ♣8  1-Buswell-Cogdill vs 8-Rankin-Adair
        140    2.50   1.50  3♠ E      2  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        140    2.50   1.50  2♠ E +1   K  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        300    1.00   3.00  3♣* S -2  J  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        620    0.00   4.00  4♠ E      K  6-Dusharme-Schneidewind vs 5-Turner-Vogt
17 ♠AT8
T86
AK92
♣K54
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠KQ93
QJ7
QJ3
♣AT7
♠J7642
2
76
♣J9862
♠5
AK9543
T854
♣Q3
14
152
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 5 5 2NT  ♣6 ♠5
EW: 2♠  ♣6 ♦2 ♥2 NT3
LoTT: 19 - 18 = +1
Par: +450 5-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  590          3.50   0.50  4♠* S     ♠K  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  590          3.50   0.50  4* S     ♠K  5-Turner-Vogt vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
  420          2.00   2.00  4 S      ♠3  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
  170          1.00   3.00  3 S +1   Q  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 8-Rankin-Adair
  130          0.00   4.00  3 N +1   2  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Buswell-Cogdill
18 ♠A3
AK8753
A9
♣T85
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠JT985
6
43
♣76432
♠K72
Q94
KJT52
♣K9
♠Q64
JT2
Q876
♣AQJ
15
112
12
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 3 5 2/1♠ 5NT
EW:  ♣4 ♦4 ♥2 ♠5 NT2
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: +660 5NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  680          3.50   0.50  4 N +2   J  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 8-Rankin-Adair
  680          3.50   0.50  4 N +2   2  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Buswell-Cogdill
  650          2.00   2.00  4 N +1       5-Turner-Vogt vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
  230          1.00   3.00  3 N +3   ♠K  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
  200          0.00   4.00  2 N +3   ♠2  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
19 ♠Q9
AQJ7
KJ54
♣632
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠8643
K862
Q963
♣T
♠K75
54
T82
♣AQJ97
♠AJT2
T93
A7
♣K854
13
510
12
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 5 5 5♠ 6NT
EW:  ♣4 ♦2 ♥1 ♠1 NT1
LoTT: 13 - 14 = -1
Par: +990 6NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  460          2.50   1.50  3N S +2   2  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  460          2.50   1.50  3N N +2   ♣A  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Buswell-Cogdill
  460          2.50   1.50  3N N +2   ♣Q  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
  460          2.50   1.50  3N N +2   ♣Q  5-Turner-Vogt vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
  450          0.00   4.00  4 N +1   ♣A  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 8-Rankin-Adair
20 ♠AKJ9
-
QT5
♣AT7542
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠7643
A9853
83
♣Q6
♠T8
KQJT642
AK4
♣9
♠Q52
7
J9762
♣KJ83
14
613
7
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4♣ 5 4♠  ♥3 NT4
EW: 4  ♣2 ♦2 ♠3 NT3
LoTT: 20 - 22 = -2
Par: +200 5*-EW-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  620          4.00   0.00  4 N      ♣K  3-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Dusharme-Schneidewind
  200          3.00   1.00  5* E -1  ♣K  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Buswell-Cogdill
        620    1.50   2.50  4 E      ♣K  5-Turner-Vogt vs 10-Angione-Lagodimos
        620    1.50   2.50  4 E      ♣3  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 8-Rankin-Adair
        790    0.00   4.00  4* E     ♣3  2-Gestiehr-Stebbins vs 9-Chaganlal-Ciolli